It sounds like a statement, but every once in a while, the words lose their order and it feels like a question. Annette Lyon wrote a post regarding the topic of religion and writing. I’m a Mormon. I’ve written books for the Mormon market. I am happy with these books for the most part. My Not So Fairy Tale Life and Seeking Zion (soon to be released) are books that fill me with satisfaction. I cannot pretend to regret the writing I’ve done.
But Robison Wells came to my house this weekend for Whitney award business and we discussed the LDS market and the national market and what the two markets meant to us. I found that both markets mean a great deal to me. But I wonder how other writers feel.
Some national authors look down on the LDS authors. They assume we aren’t as good as they are. Even some national hopefuls who haven’t ever landed a publishing deal assume LDS writers are sell-outs.
They are so wrong.
When talking to Orson Scott Card, he good-naturedly asked me what I wrote and, feeling sheepish and “less-than-worthy,” I said with an apologetic cough, “LDS fiction.” I didn’t meet his eye.
“Why are you apologizing for what you’ve written?” he asked me. “Didn’t you choose to write it?”
“Well . . . yeah, but . . .”
“And you’re published in the market you wrote for. There’s no shame in that. I think that’s great. It’s a solid market with credible writers.”
Why I needed him to tell me this is a quandary. Scott Card writes for the LDS market and he certainly isn’t a sell-out or a hack. He’s the creator of Ender! Janette Rallison wrote for the lds market and she is one of the best writers to happen to the YA market in a long time.
So why did I feel less than worthy? I know I am a fine writer. Sure, I had a rough start and wish I could alter my first two books, but I’ve hit my stride. I *know* my writing is strong.
Yet, authors exist who snicker at the local market as a sell-out. Does a different audience automatically equate to a lesser audience? Why does this undercurrent of classes exist among writers? Every book requires characterization, plot, setting, and voice in order to be successful, regardless of who’s reading and what bookstore stocks it. In the LDS “niche” it is not uncommon for an author to outsell authors in the national market.
I write what I know to the people I know best. I write in a market where I don’t have to compromise myself in order to cater to the masses. Like Annette said in her post, sometimes–even when I don’t mean to, I end up with an LDS book. I’ve come to find that this isn’t a bad thing.
I am LDS. I am a Writer. That is who I am.



Who’s got something to say?